Anyone here likes the idea of inheritance tax?

Nobody likes to be taxed again and again. I mean everyone already pays income tax. For those who qualify to pay tax yeah. Businesses pay corporate tax. Inheritance tax is thus an ‘extra’ tax and this is not like GST which is prevalent in most countries in the world. Malaysia does not have inheritance tax.

In other words, if we happened to have lots of properties and we are no longer around, those properties could be gifted to our children in the future and they do not actually lose some of it due to tax. These following countries have inheritance tax. The United Kingdom. The United States of America (some states). Japan. Germany. Hong Kong (if the value of the estate is less than HK$7.5 million)

inheritance tax

Not all advanced countries have inheritance tax yeah. Singapore does not. Australia does not. Canada does not. There has been some rumours everything we are near to the budget session but as at Budget 2020, Malaysia has no plans to introduce inheritance tax. With regard to this rumour, our Finance Minister Lim Guan Eng said, “It is unlikely. If there are, it is just a follow up of what we have announced in Budget 2019.” (full article here)  Thus, let’s just understand what is inheritance tax today.

Article in investopedia.com An inheritance tax is a tax imposed by certain states on those who inherit assets from the estate of a deceased person. Its tax rate depends on the state of residence, the value of the inheritance, and the beneficiary’s relationship to the decedent. Inheritance tax is known in some countries as a “death duty” and is occasionally called “the last twist of the taxman’s knife.”

Article in wikipedia.com An inheritance tax is a tax paid by a person who inherits money or property of a person who has died whereas an estate tax is a levy on the estate (money and property) of a person who has died. (Briefly, inheritance tax is what we pay if we receive some assets from our loved ones who have passed away. Estate tax is meanwhile a tax levied on those assets before it’s distributed. Yes, it’s possible to be taxed twice on the same assets yeah)

This is what Consumers Association of Penang (CAP) acting president Mohideen Abdul Kader said with regards to inheritance tax. He said this is the best solution to tackle problems related to wealth inequality among people in the country. He said that if implemented properly, inheritance tax would not affect those from the lower income segment.

He also shared that prior to 1991, Malaysia had estate duty and it’s applicable if the networth of the estate exceeded RM2 million. The rates were 5 percent on estates worth RM2.4million and 10 percent on everything above that. He said, “If the government wants to reintroduce inheritance tax, based on the present situation, it should be imposed on estates worth more than RM3 million to protect the people in the lower income group.” Full article here.

Personal thoughts

Personally, I would not like inheritance tax. Who would? However, if we are looking at it from the point of redistributing some wealth to the lower income (not give them directly lah but government has more funds to provide subsidies or even housing), then perhaps the effects will be positive.

The first thing which should happen first before any other taxes is however to reintroduce the GST yeah. That would help tremendously instead of trying to expand the coverage of SST. There are certainly reasons why GST has been implemented in most countries in the world. Hopefully we do not hear too much about inheritance tax again even for Budget 2021 yeah. Happy understanding.

Love news like this and more? Sign up for daily investment news updates.

Please LIKE kopiandproperty.my FB page to get daily updates about the property market beyond kopiandproperty.my articles. Else, follow me on Twitter here.

Sign up for KopiWeekly. (only once per week of property, finance, investment news and more)

Next suggested article: LHDN looking to collect higher tax for 2021


Comments

3 responses to “Anyone here likes the idea of inheritance tax?”

  1. Inheritance taxes are immoral.

    1. kopiandproperty.my avatar
      kopiandproperty.my

      I also do not like inheritance tax too. It’s double taxation in my opinion.

      1. Progressives may argue that inherited wealth is new income to the recipient(s) of the inherited wealth. However, what is truly hypocritical is when they complain that people who inherit wealth did nothing to earn it and that they are getting free stuff and yet these people want to give away free stuff on the taxpayers’ dimes. Inherited wealth costs the taxpayers nothing. Paying for freebies for other people benefits nobody.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *